Check out a2z Scrapbooking.
I think about any type of paper, light weight tin, mylar, shimmer sheetz or glitter paper would work to cut this butterfly. Try using a die for the new a2z Scrapbooking challenge "TO DIE FOR" and have fun using those shapes you've had in the closet. Get them out and dust them off. Have fun!
Hero Arts Butterfly Fancy Die at a2z Scrapbooking
Old Hero Arts set (sentiment)
Elizabeth Craft Designs embossing folder
Elizabeth Craft Designs Shimmer Sheetz
Have a great butterfly day.